CALL FOR CASES/INFORMATION: Research project on citizen participation & NV civic action to fight corruption seeks input
Syndicate content
shaazka's picture

counting textbooksI am conducting an in-depth research project to document and study cases of citizen participation and nonviolent civic action to fight corruption, in order to distill general lessons learned and best practices. The focus is on what people--organized together, exerting their collective power--are doing to fight corruption as they themselves have discerned it. The project will examine the skills, strategies, objectives, and demands of nonviolent civic campaigns and movements, rather than the phenomenon of corruption itself, or the conditions under which it occurs.  PLEASE CONTACT ME IF YOU:

  1. Know of initiatives, campaigns or movements addressing corruption that included the mobilization of citizens and/or nonviolent civic action at the local or national level. Cases may have taken place in the last two decades or be presently ongoing. Corruption may be the sole focus, or it may be linked to other concerns, such as human rights, poverty, budgets/spending, violence, authoritarian rule, organized crime, discrimination, labour rights, environmental destruction, state service provision, or other issues.
  2. Have suggestions of people or organizations to contact that might know about cases or can get the word out about the study; 
  3. Have recommendations of networks through which others can be notified about the project, including e-newsletters, websites, virtual groups, etc.
  4. Know of reports, books or articles that refer to citizen initiatives and nonviolent civic action to fight corruption.

This announcement is not a call for proposals, papers or researchers. The project is made possible through a grant from the United States Institute of Peace and support from the International Center on Nonviolent Conflict. See this PDF for additional information, including inspiring examples of civic action to fight corruption. See below for examples.

Thanks!
Shaazka Beyerle
Senior Advisor, International Center on Nonviolent Conflict

sbeyerle(at)nonviolent-conflict.org

 


counting text booksEXAMPLES OF NONVIOLENT CIVIC ACTION TO FIGHT CORRUPTION

 

  • Armenia: Anti-corruption advocates, environmental activists, and youth groups are using humor, video, animation, and creative nonviolent street actions to protect the environment from illegal building and commercial development, protest against the violation of freedom of expression and other civic rights, and support political prisoners and victims of repression.
  • Columbia: Begun in 2006, OCASA (“truth” in the Chibcha indigenous language) uses the internet and social networking--including discussion fora, training, Facebook groups and databases--to educate and mobilize youth to fight corruption.
  • Egypt: Founded by women in 2005, Shayfeen.com (play on words meaning “we see you” in Arabic) increased public awareness about corruption, fostered citizen participation, monitored the government, broadcast election fraud in real time via the internet, and proved their activities were valid under the UNCAC, to which Egypt was a signatory.
  • Guatemala: A local citizen’s movement emerged in Santa Lucia Cotzumalguapa in the aftermath of the civil war to recover the community from the hands of drug lords and organized crime, prevent electoral fraud, maintain resilience in the face of violence, defend victories, and foster social and economic development.
  • India: Established in 2007, the “Fifth Pillar” targets bribery with innovative low-risk actions such as passing out “anti-corruption” zero-rupee notes, petitioning, and anti-bribery pledges.
  • Kenya: MUHURI (Muslims for Human Rights) is empowering communities to fight poverty by curbing misuse of community development funds. It conducts local education and training in social audits, while using nonviolent tactics, such as street theatre, marches, and site visits.
  • Kuwait: In 2006, a group of young people communicating through SMS, launched the “Orange Movement” against political corruption. Their nonviolent tactics, including leafleting the parliament, enlisted public support and resulted in early parliamentary elections. Legislation to change electoral districts (to prevent corruption) became a campaign issue and was later adopted.
  • Philippines: Launched in 2003, an ongoing campaign to curb corruption in the elementary and secondary education system annually organizes about one million boy and girl scouts to count textbooks and conduct quality inspections.
  • Turkey: In 1997, the “One Minute of Darkness for Constant Light Campaign” mobilized approximately 30 million citizens in synchronized low-risk mass actions to pressure the government to take specific measures to combat corruption.

 

LOG MESSAGE
Corruption remains one of the greatest stumbling blocks to human rights, social and economic development, democracy, good governance, rule of law, and peace. But people do have power and can make their collective voice heard. Around the world, anti-corruption advocates and other civic actors are mobilizing the general public to use nonviolent strategies and tactics to fight corruption. A new research project is documenting cases. Your input could be invaluable...

 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
kantin's picture

Using zero rupee notes to protest demands for bribes

Hi Shaazka,

Thank you for sharing this intriguing research project with the New Tactics online community!  I have an example of an anti-corruption campaign that I would like to share with you.  I very happily came across this example and others from all over the world via twitter!

Zero rupee note, 5th PillarThis example comes from India, where petty corruption is an ongoing and pervasive problem.  The initiative is coordinated by an organization called the 5th Pillar, and the idea came from an Indian physics professor. Frustrated with the demands for bribes in India for public services that should be free, the professor created zero rupee notes to give to officials in protest when bribes were requested.  Vijay Anand, the president of the 5th Pillar NGO took the idea further - he printed a large number of these zero-denomination notes and distributed them widely to citizens in India. The initiative was a huge hit!  Fumiko Nagano of the Communication for Governance & Accountability Program (CommGAP) writes,

"[Anand] thought these notes would be a way to get people to show their disapproval of public service delivery dependent on bribes. The notes did just that. The first batch of 25,000 notes were met with such demand that 5th Pillar has ended up distributing one million zero-rupee notes to date since it began this initiative. Along the way, the organization has collected many stories from people using them to successfully resist engaging in bribery.

One such story was our earlier case about the old lady and her troubles with the Revenue Department official over a land title. Fed up with requests for bribes and equipped with a zero rupee note, the old lady handed the note to the official. He was stunned. Remarkably, the official stood up from his seat, offered her a chair, offered her tea and gave her the title she had been seeking for the last year and a half to obtain without success. Had the zero rupee note reached the old lady sooner, her granddaughter could have started college on schedule and avoided the consequence of delaying her education for two years. In another experience, a corrupt official in a district in Tamil Nadu was so frightened on seeing the zero rupee note that he returned all the bribe money he had collected for establishing a new electricity connection back to the no longer compliant citizen."

Why was this tactic such a success? Anand believes that the officials' fear of setting off disciplinary proceedings is a big factor.  More importantly, however, is the willingness of the people to use the zero rupee notes.  People are no longer afraid to stand up to the practice of corruption, especially now that they know they are no alone in this fight. Fumiko writes, 

"This last point—people knowing that they are not alone in the fight—seems to be the biggest hurdle when it comes to transforming norms vis-à-vis corruption. For people to speak up against corruption that has become institutionalized within society, they must know that there are others who are just as fed up and frustrated with the system. Once they realize that they are not alone, they also realize that this battle is not unbeatable. Then, a path opens up—a path that can pave the way for relatively simple ideas like the zero rupee notes to turn into a powerful social statement against petty corruption."

For the full article, please read Fumiko Nagano's blog post titled 'Paying Zero for Public Services.'  For lots of other examples of civil society action against corruption, see Fumiko's other posts under the tag 'Anti-Corruption.' 

[Photo credit: 5th Pillar]

Kristin Antin, New Tactics Online Community Builder

 

kantin's picture

You already have this one!

Hi Shaazka, 

Just realized that you already have this example! Sorry to duplicate your efforts! I hope we get some new examples on here for you...

Kristin Antin, New Tactics Online Community Builder

shaazka's picture

Civic action to fight corruption

Shaazka Beyerle, The International Center on Nonviolent Conflict

No worries. Thanks a lot Kristin! It's great that you are sharing more details about Fifth Pillar, a really innovative and exciting campaign that is going national in India.

satwood's picture

Of Geckos and Crocodiles: Indonesia’s Corruption Eradication Eff

This is an interesting illustration of the effectiveness of non-violent citizen action protesting in this case the efforts of the police and government authorities to shut down their own anti-corruption commission that was becoming threatening to their own power.

In a blog post titled, '“Saya Cicak” (I am a Gecko): The Power of Public Support' Fumiko Nagano writes, 

"In 2002, Indonesia established an anti-corruption commission (called the Corruption For me, the most striking point of the presentation was that people came to KPK’s defense when state authorities began to clamp down on itEradication Commission, or “KPK” for short in Indonesian).

The KPK became so good at its job of fighting corruption (Corruption Crimes Court, which is attached to the KPK, has a 100% conviction rate) that it began to threaten state authorities, antagonizing the police and the Attorney Generals’ office in particular. Direct attacks to undermine the KPK ensued, leading to an arrest by the police in late October 2009 of two KPK deputy chairmen, Chandra Hamzah and Bibit Samad Rianto, on charges of abuse of power. During the two men’s court hearings in November, hours of wiretapped conversation, allegedly between members of the police and the attorney general’s office, were played. On the tape, the speakers were heard plotting to frame the KPK for bribery in an effort to undermine the Commission.

The tape recordings were widely picked up by the media, triggering a huge public outcry in Indonesia. In a country where people do not have a tradition of public demonstrations to demand what they want, ordinary Indonesians took to the street for days to show their support for the KPK. Responding to the former chief detective Susno Duadji’s comment likening the KPK going against the police force as a “gecko fighting a crocodile,” people started a movement, “Saya Cicka,” Indonesian for “I am a Gecko,” demonstrating their solidarity with the anti-corruption commission. They also created banners reading “Say No to Buaya (crocodiles).”In addition to street protests, Indonesians also turned to social media. On Facebook, a university lecturer created a group supporting the KPK and protesting the actions of the police. Named “Gerakan 1.000.000 Facebookers Dukung Chandra Hamzah & Bibit Samad Rianto” (Movement of 1,000,000 Facebookers Supporting Chandra Hamzah & Bibit Samad Rianto), this cause quickly gained support; as of today, the group has more than 1.3 million members. The overwhelming display of public support for the KPK led to two concrete actions: the President set up a fact-finding team to probe the case, and high-level officials from the police force and Attorney Generals’ office resigned amid the controversies over the wiretap.

This is a powerful story of what can happen when public mobilizes around a cause."

 I think this is the kind of example you are looking for?

Edit: The author of this blog  is looking for case studies as are you - good contact.

Susan Atwood Global leadership instructor University of Minnesota 

 

shaazka's picture

Civic action to fight corruption

Shaazka Beyerle, The International Center on Nonviolent Conflict

Hi Susan, Thanks for highlighting the Indonesian case. This is a very good example of civic action to fight corruption.   And it's also important for illustrating the role that civic action can play to support and defend public officials with integrity and institutions that are fighting corruption.

IF YOU KNOW OF OTHERS, PLEASE LET ME KNOW. Are you also doing research in this field?

nguforp's picture

Interested in the findings

Hi,

i have been keen on corruption  particularly as it pertains to the police. I have my LLM disseratation of 2007 on POLICE CORRUPTION IN CAMEROON AND UGANDA: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS. Here corruption was looked at as a human rights violation.

A am now working on a PHD hteses on THE IMAGE OF THE POLICE IN AFRICAN FICTION. I have achapter consecrated to corruption. I will be  very delighted to have simple practcl examples of success stories in this vein from around theglobe.

Thanks in advance.

My address nguforpatyahoo [dot] com.

 

shaazka's picture

police corruption

Hello. Thanks for your comment. The Guatemala case mentioned in the attachment of my blog involves, in part, police corruption and the larger related issue of impunity. I've learned about another local nonviolent campaign in Mexico. I'll be looking into it as well. I'll make a note to keep you posted of the research. In the meantime, would it be possible to get a copy of your LLM disseration on police corruption in Cameroon and Uganda? Best, Shaazka

Pel Advocates's picture

Deomocray and Women Participation A tool to fighting Corruption

Dear Shaazka:

  • Liberia: 2006: Great to hear this, Partners for the Promotion of Girls Education in Liberia is one group working on such project to enhance trasparecny and curb corruption. Women participation is cardinal in every sector from promoting to enchancing and entrenching their economic, social and cultural rights. The work in this direction begin with the formulation of the Liberia Civil Society Budget Watch Network, Partners For the Promotion of Girls Education in Liberia is one women/girls organization that is using non violent movement to curb corruption at the local level. By tracking the the flow of companies social fund and the county development fund in leeward counties in Liberia. They are located in Bong County, central Liberia.

My contact details: Pel_advocatesatyahoo [dot] co [dot] uk or alfredwrehatyahoo [dot] co [dot] uk

shaazka's picture

Democracy and women's participation

Hello Alfred: Thanks for writing back and sharing the info about Liberia! I've been a bit out of contact due to travel and sick leave. I'll send you a separate email to follow-up. Am very interested to learn more about the Liberia Civil Society Budget Watch Network and the Partners for the Promotion of Girls Eduction. Best, Shaazka

Login or register to subscribe to receive email notifications for this dialogue.